International experts call upon world community to stop Chinese government from implementing new law on religion before it is too late

By- VIJAY KRANTI

New Delhi, New York, London, Taipei : October 2 A group of leading international experts
on China has drawn the attention of world community to stop Chinese President Xi Jinping from
imposing a new law which is aimed at eradicating all religious faiths like Buddhism, Christianity and
Islam in China. Although the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) claims that this law, titled as ‘Order-19’, is
aimed at “standardizing the management of places of religious activity” but in actual practice it is
nothing short of what they termed as the ‘communistization’ of religion. Since this law is going to
severely hurt the sentiments of millions of Chinese citizens as well as those belonging to occupied and

colonized countries like Tibet, East Turkistan (Xinjiang) and Southern Mongolia the world institutions
should act before it is too late.
The webinar, jointly organized by the Centre for Himalayan Asia Studies and Engagement (CHASE) and
Tibetan Youth Congress (TYC).The experts who participated were Dr. Chienyu Shi of Taiwan Institute for
National Defence and Security Research from Taipei; Dr. Chin Jin, Chairperson of Federation for a
Democratic China from Sydney; Dr. Enver Bughda, a prominent Uyghur activist and medical surgeon
from London who exposed the ongoing racket of organ harvesting in China; and Mr. Enghebatu
Togochog, a Mongol writer and editor of ‘Southern Mongolia Watch” from New York. Mr. Sonam
Tsering, General Secretary of TYC and Co-host of the webinar gave vote of thanks while Prof. (Ms.)
Aayushi Ketkar, of Special Centre for National Security Studies JNU handled the question-answer
session. Vijay Kranti, a senior journalist, Tibetologist and Chairman CHASE hosted the event as
moderator.
Dr. Chin Jin said that ‘Order-19’ which Beijing claims to strengthen the regulation and management of
religious venues is in reality adding further restrictions on religious freedom. He said that it is
unfortunate that even some high ranking religious leaders, living in the free world, like Pope Francis of
Rome and Buddhist masters from Taiwan like Hsing Yun and Master Chin Kung willingly submitted to
CCP’s dictations. “While the Pope and the two Buddhist masters asked the Catholic and Buddhist
followers in China and Hong Kong to submit to the CCP, Master Chin Kung even went as far as calling Xi
Jinping a ‘Bodhisattva’ incarnation,” he added.
However, sounding a note of optimism Dr. Chin Jin said, “Only when various forces and factors converge
to bring about the fall of the CCP, will the restrictions and oppression on religious freedom in Tibet and
other regions come to an end and disappear” he added.

Presenting his analysis of President Xi Jinping’s policies on religion in the context of the new Chinese law

under “Order-19,” Dr. Chienyu Shih raised three pertinent questions. His first question was “Is there
really any space for religious freedom in China which can be or needs to be governed?” His second
question was “What do they mean by ‘Sinicizing’?” And the third was “What is the strategy of Xi and
other communists to make ‘Sinicization’ of religions happen? And how much have they succeeded so
far?”
Giving his own understanding of the idea of ‘Sinicization’ of religion in real terms is, what he termed as,
‘Communistization’ of religion. “There is no Church, meaning the ‘Church’ of any religion, in today’s
China. The ultimate authority of every such institution lies in the CCP. They are focused on developing
communist cadres as the religious leaders – with the final aim of developing political loyalty to the CCP
among the faith holders,” he said adding that, The CCP’s policy on religion is quite simple. You have to
forget whether you are a Mongol, a Tibetan or an Uyghur – not to mention of the Taiwanese, Hong
Kongers. No matter which ethnicity you belong to or where you come from, you have simply to go under
the CCP’s rule.”
Dr. Enver Bughda said, “Communism can function and gain control only in chaos. Where there is no
chaos, they just create it to find a role for themselves. This is exactly what President Xi is doing in the
world today. Inside China it’s a history of nothing but chaos. Now what Xi is doing with religion through
various policies is to create chaos in order to control the entire religious system. Current ‘Order-19’ is a
part of that game.” Underlining the CCP’s policy of keeping itself above the God he said, ”In today’s
China there is no place for Allah or Jesus or Buddha at the top in one’s faith. It has to be the CCP and Xi
Jinping on the top. They are worse than the Taliban in Afghanistan where they blasted a big statue of
Buddha. In today’s Tibet they are destroying all big statues of Buddha. “
Dr. Bughda gave an interesting example of double standards being adopted and practiced by President
Xi on religion. “In the beginning of ongoing Asian Games in China Xi took the visiting King and Queen of
Syria to a temple for prayers. It looks absurd because the guest King and the Queen were practicing
Muslims who would not pray in a temple. But the real game of Xi was to offer prayers for the safety of
his own kingdom without being noticed by the communist cadres and others for going to a temple and
praying.”
Striking a sad note about the situation in Southern Mongolia which happens to be under China’s colonial
occupation since 1919, Mr. Enghebatu Togochog said, “In my country no religion is left which can be
further destroyed by President Xi Jinping’s new law on religion. Soon after coming to power in 1949
Chairman Mao’s CCP attacked and destroyed every symbol of our Buddhist national identity. They did it
because of vengeance against the Mongols who had ruled over China for many centuries. They killed
and eliminated our entire class of elites to ensure that no sign of our nationality could survive. Today
they are bent upon destroying or language by imposing Mandarin Chinese language at every level. Even
the traditional nomad yak and goat herders have been forced to quit their lifestyle on the fake ground of
protecting environment.”

In his vote of thanks as the co-host of the webinar Sonam Tsering, the General Secretary of Tibetan
Youth Congress and a popular youth leader among the Tibetan diaspora, said that the Chinese
government has been making all efforts to erase the Tibetan national identity through destruction of
institutions and re-education of monks in the communist way. They are trying to occupy the Tibetan
tradition of reincarnation of senior religious leaders, including that of the Dalai Lama, which is unique in
the world. “Since 2009 the TYC observes 13 th July as a special day to oppose China’s interference in the
reincarnation system. Such moves show the Chinese leaders’ desperation for failure to eradicate love
and devotion for His Holiness the Dalai Lama from the hearts of the Tibetan people. ‘Order-19’ is just
another expression of their frustration,” he said.
Vijay Kranti, a veteran Indian Tibetologist who is also the Chairman of CHASE and the host of the show,
presented the Tibetan perspective on the state of religion inside Chinese occupied Tibet. Tracing the
history of Chinese policy on Tibetan Buddhism since 1951 he said that the current decision of imposing
their ‘Order-19’ by the Beijing masters of Tibet is the fourth and, perhaps, the last stage of eradicating
religion completely out of Tibetan people’s social, cultural and political life. He referred to the 1951-
1959 era as the first stage when Mao, his PLA and CCP promised autonomy on religion and cultural
matters only to back out leading to the Tibetan uprising of 1959 against the Chinese colonial rule. In the
second stage Mao and subsequent communist leaders of China tried aggressively to destroy people’s
faith in Buddha Dharma and the exiled Dalai Lama hoping that it will force the ordinary Tibetans to
behave as true ‘Patriotic Chinese’.
“However, when widespread Tibetan uprisings happened in 1987 and 1989 only then Beijing’s
communist leadership realized the power of religion and adopted a new strategy of occupying religion
from within as their third attempt to tame the Tibetans. This stage has been especially focused on
implanting CCP’s stooges as new incarnate Lamas at every possible place and increasing CCP control on
all religious institutions of Tibet. It was finally the Tibetan uprising of 2008 and the emergence of Xi
Jinping as the ‘Paramount Leader’ of the CCP that the fourth strategy of annihilating the Tibetan religion
and national identity completely has been taken up. By snatching hundreds of thousands of Tibetan
children from their parents and pushing these kids into regimented CCP residential schools they are now
hoping for a new generation of Tibet which will be visually Tibetan but mentally they will be CCP’s
robots. ‘Order-19’ is just the concluding part of this campaign which covers the rest of Tibetan society,”
said Kranti.

58^th Anniversary of “Tibet Autonomous Region”

XI JINPING AND CCP FOCUSED AT WIPING OUT IDENTITY OF TIBET, XIJIANG AND S. MONGOLIA

 Report by: VIJAY KRANTI

New Delhi, Paris, New York & Dharamshala – 28 August 2023

Many international experts on China and Tibet are of the opinion that President Xi Jinping’s obsession with security and to present himself as the new Mao Zedong is resulting into cultural genocide and total annihilation of the national personality of China’s colonies like Tibet, East Turkistan (Xinjiang) and Southern Mongolia. Analyzing the causes and impact of dividing occupied Tibet in 1965 into many pieces at an international webinar titled “China’s Cartographic Colonialism in Tibet” experts from USA, Europe, Tibet and India expressed concern that China’s Communist Party (CCP) and its leaders are religiously focused at washing out Tibet’s history by rewriting and propagating a manufactured version that suits Chinese expansionism.

The webinar, jointly organized by the Centre for Himalayan Asia Studies and Engagement (CHASE) and Tibetan Youth Congress (TYC) this Saturday evening, marked the eve of 58^th anniversary of Mao’s decision to break occupied Tibet into many parts and branding one of these parts as ‘Tibet Autonomous Region’ (TAR) on 1^st September 1965. Fourteen years after occupying Tibet in 1951, Mao chopped off many parts of Kham and Amdo provinces from original Tibet and merged them into adjoining Chinese provinces of Yunnan, Sichuan, Qinghai and Gansu. Beijing celebrates this day every year as a special day of reforms in Tibet.

The experts who shared their views in this webinar included Pierre Antoine Donnet from Paris, a well-known author of books on China and former new bureau correspondent of AFP in Beijing; Dr. Uwe Meya a veteran expert on Tibet and a member of the board of directors in the Swiss-Tibet Friendship Association (GSTF); Tenzin Sampho, the head of US-Tibet Coalition who is also an expert and active supporter on asylum matters and human rights in USA. Vijay Kranti, Chairman CHASE and a renowned journalist and Tibetologist moderated the webinar while Gonpo Dhundup , President of TYC delivered vote of thanks. Prof. Aaayushi Ketkar of JNU and expert in international and security matters handled the question-answer session.

Dr Uwe Meya, a well-known Swiss expert on Tibet who extensively traveled through Tibet when China decided to open Tibet to exploit its international tourism potentials, described China’s policy on Tibet as ‘Colonialism of Perception’. Supporting this concept he said that the Chinese propaganda machinery has been consistently focused at managing and promoting this perception among the international community that Tibet is not an occupied ‘country’ but is just another  ‘region in South West China’; or that Tibetans are not a ‘people’ but just one of the ‘nationalities’ or a ‘minority’ community within China. “It is unfortunate that a big section of international media and other opinion makers have fallen into this trap of China,” he said.

He also pointed out that the Xi Jinping’s government is now bent upon washing out the Tibetan names of Tibetan cities, towns and regions from the international memory and usage. “Two months ago the CCP has formally banned using word ‘Tibet’ and to replace it with the Chinese name ‘Xizang’. President Xi Jinping is now focused at removing the mention of word ‘Tibet’ in all areas right from politics to science. Even Wikipedia too has started using it. And this is what I call colonialism of perception,” he said.

Mr. Pierre Antoine Donnet presented a detailed analysis of how the consistently weakening economic situation in China and increasing public disappointment with President Xi due to growing unemployment and the impact of mismanagement of the Covid on Chinese people’s lives have made Xi feel very insecure. “A new winter is descending on China. Even while the Chinese leaders have learnt many lessons from developments like the breakup of Soviet Union, fall of the Berlin Wall and events of 1989 at Tianmen Square in China, yet the CCP looks doomed. As a result of this the situation in China for the CCP and its leaders, especially President Xi Jinping is becoming more and more fragile – month by month.”

He specifically pointed at China’s efforts to assimilate the Tibetans and the Uyghur communities into the Han identity. “Chinese leaders and the CCP have failed to realize that only material policies are not enough for the human beings. This is especially proving  true for the Tibetan people and the people of Xinjiang,” he added.

Mr. Tenzin Sampho from New York, who was born and brought up in Chinese occupied Tibet,  gave details of how China is using language and education to eradicate the distinct personality of Tibet. “In my early years we used to get our education in Tibetan language till the fifth standard and then the medium of instruction would change to Mandarin. But now Chinese administration takes away even small children from their homes in very early age and puts them into residential schools where the only language is Chinese and they are exposed to strong communist brainwashing. The CCP is bent upon Sinicizing every Tibetan to finish Tibet’s own identity permanently. Very soon a real Tibetan might become a special piece for Chinese museums,” he said.

Speaking about the division of original Tibet and assimilation of many parts of historic Tibet into neighboring provinces of China, Tenzin said that there is very strict control on the movement of Tibetans living in these provinces. “One has to seek special official authorization to travel from one place to another. There are dozens of police checking points on every road. The people of Amdo and Kham are not allowed to travel to TAR — not even to go to Lhasa for pilgrimage,” he added.

Introducing the subject and the panelists to the audience Vijay Kranti said that Chairman Mao was quite worried over the rising international awareness about the deteriorating situation of human rights in Tibet and the undying spirit of Tibetan people for freedom from China. That is why he created TAR only to deceive the world community and make it believe that only this part was Tibet. Moreover he wanted to dilute the Tibetan resistance against Chinese occupation by distributing Tibetan populations of Kham and Amdo to adjoining provinces of China.

While giving his vote of Thanks, Gonpo Dhundup, President of TYC made it clear that his organization and the people of Tibet are fighting for the independence of entire Tibet and not just for TAR which was created by China to fool the world. When we talk of Tibet it clearly means all three regions of Tibet which are U-Tsang, Kham and Amdo. A very large number among 157 self-immolations in Tibet in recent years are from areas outside TAR. It shows that Tibetan people from all three provinces are struggling for freedom from Chinese colonial occupation,” he said.